A London impulse leg on a Tuesday ran from 4,412.00 to 4,458.00 between 07:05 and 07:40 UTC on strong, one-directional 15-minute candles — a $46 move with no counter-candle larger than a third of the average impulse body. The 4-hour trend had been higher for three sessions, and the economic calendar was clear until 13:30 UTC.
Worked example · winner
Post-London-open retest into a triple confluence zone
Impulse leg 4,412.00 to 4,458.00, 07:05–07:40 UTC. Confluence zone drawn at the 50% retracement (4,435.00), overlapping the 15m 20 EMA at 4,434.20 and session VWAP at 4,433.80 — three references within $1.20 of each other.
- Level
- 50% retracement of the impulse leg, 4,435.00, confirmed by 15m 20 EMA and VWAP within $1.20
- Retracement depth
- $23.00 / 50.0% of the impulse leg
- Shape check
- Three retracement candles averaged smaller bodies than the three impulse candles — corrective
- Trigger
- 08:15 UTC — 15m candle closed at 4,436.90, reclaiming roughly 60% of its own range off a low of 4,433.60
- Entry
- 4,436.90, filled on a stop-entry above the trigger candle high
- Stop
- 4,431.60, beyond the pullback extreme (4,433.60) plus a $2.00 buffer — $5.30 risk per ounce
- Size
- £200 ÷ ($5.30 × $100) ≈ 0.37 lots
- Target 1
- Prior impulse extreme, 4,458.00 — reached 09:52 UTC, half closed, stop moved to break-even
- Target 2
- Extension to 4,471.00 on the remainder, reached 11:40 UTC
- Result
- +3.6R blended across both tranches
Every item on the standard trigger checklist passed before entry: the zone was marked while the impulse leg was still running, three separate confluence references landed within a narrow band, the retracement candles were visibly smaller-bodied than the impulse candles, and the trigger candle reclaimed well over the required third of its range.
The stop distance of $5.30 sat inside the normal $4–$9 band described on the risk-management page for this setup, which meant sizing at 0.37 lots kept the position within the standard 1% risk without any adjustment for an unusually wide or unusually tight stop.
Management followed the standard rule: half closed at the first target with the stop moved to break-even, letting the second half run to a further extension once the trend showed no sign of stalling at the original impulse high.
What it teaches: The best pullback trades are unremarkable in hindsight — a pre-marked zone, genuine confluence, a corrective shape, and a mechanical exit. Nothing about the winning trade required a discretionary judgement call at any single step.
Worked example · loser
A textbook setup that gold simply invalidated
A Thursday NY overlap retest of a London break. Impulse leg 4,501.00 to 4,536.00, 13:05–13:35 UTC, ahead of no scheduled release. 4-hour trend aligned higher for four sessions. Confluence zone at the 61.8% retracement (4,514.60), overlapping a broken swing level at 4,515.40.
- Level
- 61.8% retracement, 4,514.60, confirmed by a broken swing level at 4,515.40
- Retracement depth
- $21.40 / 61.2% of the impulse leg — inside the deep-but-tradable band
- Shape check
- Retracement candle bodies smaller than impulse candles — corrective, passed
- Trigger
- 14:20 UTC — 15m candle closed at 4,516.80, reclaiming roughly 45% of its range
- Entry
- 4,516.80
- Stop
- 4,511.20, beyond the pullback extreme (4,513.10) plus a $2.00 buffer — $5.60 risk per ounce
- Size
- £200 ÷ ($5.60 × $100) ≈ 0.36 lots — half size applied for a 61.8%+ depth, per the risk-management rule, so 0.18 lots taken
- What happened
- Price stalled at the reclaim level for 25 minutes, then broke back below 4,511.20 on a fresh bearish 15m candle at 15:05 UTC with no news catalyst
- Result
- -1.0R, stop filled at planned level with no meaningful slippage
Every checklist item passed, including the half-size adjustment required by the risk-management rule for a 61.8%+ retracement — this was not an execution failure. The retracement depth, the confluence stack, the corrective shape and the trigger candle all met the stated standard.
The stall at the reclaim level for over twenty minutes without progress toward the mid-range target was itself a documented invalidation warning from the hub page's management rules, and the position was still open when the fresh bearish candle broke the stop level cleanly.
Nothing here indicates the setup or the trader's discipline was at fault. A well-specified continuation setup with a genuine edge still loses on individual trades when the underlying flow simply reverses — this loss belongs in the "valid" column of the journal, not the "violation" column.
What it teaches: A loss that followed every rule correctly is not evidence the strategy is broken. It is the expected cost of trading a setup that does not, and should not, win every time — the value of the checklist is that it lets this trade be filed correctly rather than triggering an unnecessary strategy review.
Worked example · loser
The trade that should never have been taken — impulsive shape ignored
A Monday London-session move from 4,388.00 to 4,421.00 between 08:10 and 08:50 UTC. The retracement that followed sat at the 50% level, inside the standard continuation band, but was built from three large one-directional 15-minute candles rather than a corrective drift.
- Level
- 50% retracement, 4,404.50, loosely overlapping a round-number reference at 4,405.00
- Retracement depth
- $16.50 / 50.0% — inside the textbook zone by depth alone
- Shape check
- Failed — the three retracement candles averaged a larger body size than the three impulse candles, signalling a reversal rather than a pullback
- Trigger taken anyway
- 09:05 UTC — a 15m candle closed at 4,406.20 after a shallow one-candle pause, treated as a valid reclaim
- Entry
- 4,406.20
- Stop
- 4,401.80, beyond the recent low plus a $1.50 buffer — $4.40 risk per ounce
- Size
- £200 ÷ ($4.40 × $100) ≈ 0.45 lots
- What happened
- Price continued falling through the stop and through the entire impulse leg's origin by 10:40 UTC — the move had been a reversal from the start, not a pullback
- Result
- -1.0R on the stop, but representative of a trade that carried far more downside risk than the R figure suggests, since the same read on a larger position would have compounded the shape error
The depth measurement was correct and is exactly why this trade is instructive: a setup can pass the numerical fibonacci filter completely while failing the qualitative shape filter, and depth alone was enough to make the entry feel justified in the moment.
The shape check — comparing average candle body size between the retracement and the impulse leg it was supposedly correcting — should have stood down this trade before the trigger candle was even evaluated. The retracement candles were visibly larger-bodied on the chart, a fact recorded in the pre-entry notes and then overridden.
The post-trade review identified the override explicitly: the trader noted in the journal that the shape looked "a bit aggressive but the level is clean," which is the exact pattern described on the psychology page as entering a pullback that is really a reversal. The stop loss limited the damage to a single R, but the trade was a rule violation, not a valid loss, and was tagged accordingly rather than being filed alongside Trade 2.
What it teaches: Depth passing the filter does not mean the trade passes the filter. Shape is checked first, and a corrective read is a precondition for evaluating the fibonacci level at all — not a secondary nice-to-have once the level already looks attractive.