Gold comparisons

    GOLDHUNTS VS NOTION AND EXCEL TEMPLATES

    A spreadsheet is free, infinitely flexible and completely yours — and it depends on you typing every gold trade in correctly, forever. Gold Hunts imports MT5 gold trades automatically and computes session, sweep and dollar-risk statistics. Templates win on customisation; automation wins on survival past month three.

    THE VERDICT IN ONE TABLE

    Almost every serious trader starts in a spreadsheet, and that is not a mistake. Building your own columns forces you to decide what you actually measure, and a Notion or Excel template costs nothing but attention.

    The failure is predictable and it is not about features. Manual journals decay: entries get skipped on losing days, which is precisely when the data matters, and levels get typed from memory hours later. What survives is a partial record biased towards the trades you felt good about.

    • MT5 account sync

      Gold Hunts

      Yes

      MetaTrader 5 login, password and server; closed gold trades and open XAU positions import automatically.

      Notion / Excel template

      No

      No broker connection. Every trade is typed in, or pasted from an exported statement and reconciled by hand.

    • Gold-specific analytics

      Gold Hunts

      Yes

      Every metric is XAUUSD-native: 100 oz per lot, so a $1.00 move is $100 per 1.00 lot and a 30-cent spread is $30 per round turn.

      Notion / Excel template

      No

      Only what you build. Gold formulas must be written and maintained yourself.

    • XAU session breakdown (Asia / London / NY)

      Gold Hunts

      Yes

      Preset gold windows — London 07:00–16:00 UTC and New York 12:00–21:00 UTC — applied to every trade with no configuration.

      Notion / Excel template

      No

      Possible with formulas, but you convert every timestamp to UTC and bucket it manually.

    • Sweep and setup tagging built in

      Gold Hunts

      Yes

      Sweep, continuation and reversal ship as a default gold taxonomy rather than tags you invent.

      Notion / Excel template

      Partial

      Fully customisable tagging, entirely dependent on tagging discipline.

    • Prop-firm daily-loss reporting

      Gold Hunts

      Partial

      Daily realised gold P&L and drawdown tracking on a Europe/London day boundary; not a per-firm rules engine.

      Notion / Excel template

      No

      A daily-loss tracker can be built, but it will not warn you in time.

    • Data export

      Gold Hunts

      Yes

      CSV and JSON export of your own gold history, plus public JSON endpoints at /gold-data.

      Notion / Excel template

      Yes

      The file is yours — the strongest thing about this option.

    • Mobile

      Gold Hunts

      Yes

      Installable PWA — works from the browser on iOS and Android, no app store.

      Notion / Excel template

      Partial

      Mobile spreadsheet entry is possible and unpleasant.

    • Free tier

      Gold Hunts

      Yes

      Free with no trade cap and no card required.

      Notion / Excel template

      Yes

      Free, or a one-off template purchase.

    • Price

      Gold Hunts

      Yes

      £0.

      Notion / Excel template

      Yes

      Usually £0, plus your time — the real cost.

    Assessed against a typical self-built or purchased trading journal template in Excel, Google Sheets or Notion. No specific vendor template is being rated.

    BEST FOR

    Templates are genuinely the right answer in a few cases — here they are.

    • You take under ten trades a month and want total control of the columns: template.
    • You are designing a bespoke metric nobody has built yet: template.
    • You need an offline file with no third-party account anywhere: template.
    • You trade gold daily and cannot keep up with manual entry: Gold Hunts.
    • You want session, sweep and dollar-risk analysis without writing formulas: Gold Hunts.

    THE GOLD FORMULAS YOU WOULD HAVE TO BUILD

    To reach a gold-native view in a spreadsheet you need, at minimum: a conversion from lot size to dollars per $1.00 move (100 ounces per lot, so 1.00 lot equals $100), a spread-cost column in dollars per round turn, a UTC conversion for every entry timestamp, a session bucket keyed to London 07:00–16:00 UTC and New York 12:00–21:00 UTC, a stop-distance column in dollars of gold price, and an economic-calendar cross-reference so you can see whether the loss happened inside a data release.

    All of that is buildable in an afternoon. The problem is the two hundredth trade, not the first — every column above must be filled correctly on a day you were stopped out twice and did not want to look at the account.

    What you want to knowSpreadsheet cost
    Risk in dollars per gold lotA formula, plus correct lot size typed on every row
    Session attributionUTC conversion plus a bucketing formula on every row
    Spread cost per round turnRequires recording bid and ask at entry — rarely done in practice
    Sweep versus continuation outcomeManual classification, applied consistently for months
    Daily realised loss against a limitBuildable, but it reports after the fact rather than during the day

    WHERE A TEMPLATE IS GENUINELY STRONGER

    Ownership and privacy. The file lives on your machine, works offline, and depends on nobody's uptime or business model.

    Unlimited customisation. If you want a column for how many hours you slept, nothing stops you, and no product roadmap has to agree.

    Zero lock-in. No account, no sync, no migration. For traders who value that above convenience, it is a legitimate choice.

    MIGRATION NOTES

    Keep the spreadsheet. Connect MetaTrader 5 to Gold Hunts so the objective record — fills, times, levels, outcomes — builds itself from broker data, and reserve the sheet for the things only you can supply, such as why you took the trade.

    Historical gold trades import automatically from the MT5 account history, so you do not have to backfill anything you never typed in.

    If you want the automated record back out again, Gold Hunts exports CSV and JSON, so your spreadsheet workflow can continue on top of clean data instead of hand-typed data.

    THE GOLD ARITHMETIC A GENERAL TOOL DOES NOT ASSUME

    One XAUUSD lot is 100 ounces. A $1.00 move in the gold price is therefore $100 per 1.00 lot, $10 per 0.10 lot and $1 per 0.01 lot. Everything else — stop distance, spread cost, position size — falls out of that single conversion, and a tool that does not know it cannot tell you what your risk actually was.

    Spread on gold is quoted in cents. A 25-cent spread costs $25 per round turn per 1.00 lot before commission; through a United States inflation release the same symbol can quote $1.50 or wider, which is $150 per round turn per lot for the same trade you took an hour earlier. Read across a month of scalps, that difference decides whether the strategy is viable.

    Session windows matter as much as levels. London runs 07:00–16:00 UTC and New York 12:00–21:00 UTC, with the overlap from 12:00 to 16:00 UTC carrying most of gold's daily range expansion. A journal that reports "morning" and "afternoon" in your local time hides the only boundaries gold respects.

    • Contract: 1.00 lot XAUUSD = 100 ounces
    • $1.00 gold move = $100 per 1.00 lot
    • 25-cent spread = $25 per round turn per 1.00 lot
    • London 07:00–16:00 UTC, New York 12:00–21:00 UTC, overlap 12:00–16:00 UTC

    WHAT THIS PAGE DOES NOT CLAIM

    No ratings, scores, testimonials or user counts appear on this page, because none could be verified. What is compared is feature presence, published price and whether the tool models gold correctly.

    Gold Hunts publishes no profit or return figures for any product, including its own. Performance is reported only as a win rate on a disclosed trade count with losing calls left visible on the public ledger.

    RISK NOTE

    Leveraged gold carries a high risk of rapid loss. Everything on this page is education, not financial advice or a projection of returns.

    GOLD TRADING FAQ

    Is a spreadsheet trading journal good enough?
    For low trade counts and full control, yes. It stops being good enough when entry volume outpaces your willingness to type, because the missing rows are almost always the losing days.
    Can Excel do gold session analysis?
    Yes, with a UTC conversion and a bucketing formula keyed to London 07:00–16:00 UTC and New York 12:00–21:00 UTC. You maintain it; a gold journal presets it.
    What does a template genuinely do better?
    Ownership, offline access, privacy and unlimited custom columns. Those are real advantages and no automated journal fully replaces them.
    Can I use a template alongside Gold Hunts?
    Yes, and it is the setup we would recommend: automated objective data from the MT5 sync, and your own sheet for reasoning and notes. Exports are available in CSV and JSON.
    Do I have to re-enter my old gold trades?
    No. Connecting MetaTrader 5 imports your existing closed gold history, so the record starts populated rather than empty.

    RELATED READING

    COMPARE IT ON YOUR OWN DATA

    Live XAUUSD signals on a public ledger, a free gold trade journal that syncs with MetaTrader 5, and the macro pulse before the London open.

    MORE IN THIS COMPARISON