Gold comparisons

    GOLDHUNTS VS EDGEWONK

    Gold Hunts automates the gold record: MT5 sync, XAU session splits and sweep tagging, free. Edgewonk is a paid one-year licence built around deliberate manual entry, emotional tagging and a Tiltmeter. If your problem is discipline rather than data, Edgewonk earns its fee.

    THE VERDICT IN ONE TABLE

    These two tools disagree about what a journal is for. Edgewonk's position is that typing the trade in is the work: the reflection, the emotional state, the deviation from plan. Its Tiltmeter and custom criteria exist to surface behavioural patterns, not broker statistics.

    Gold Hunts takes the opposite position for gold specifically: the broker already knows what happened, so import it, classify it by session and setup, and spend your attention on the review rather than the data entry.

    • MT5 account sync

      Gold Hunts

      Yes

      MetaTrader 5 login, password and server; closed gold trades and open XAU positions import automatically.

      Edgewonk

      Partial

      Trade import is supported from platform statements; the workflow is designed around manual entry and reflection.

    • Gold-specific analytics

      Gold Hunts

      Yes

      Every metric is XAUUSD-native: 100 oz per lot, so a $1.00 move is $100 per 1.00 lot and a 30-cent spread is $30 per round turn.

      Edgewonk

      Partial

      Strong general analytics and custom criteria, but nothing gold-specific out of the box.

    • XAU session breakdown (Asia / London / NY)

      Gold Hunts

      Yes

      Preset gold windows — London 07:00–16:00 UTC and New York 12:00–21:00 UTC — applied to every trade with no configuration.

      Edgewonk

      No

      No preset gold session windows; you would build time-of-day segmentation with custom criteria.

    • Sweep and setup tagging built in

      Gold Hunts

      Yes

      Sweep, continuation and reversal ship as a default gold taxonomy rather than tags you invent.

      Edgewonk

      Partial

      Custom setups and criteria are a core feature — you define the sweep taxonomy yourself.

    • Prop-firm daily-loss reporting

      Gold Hunts

      Partial

      Daily realised gold P&L and drawdown tracking on a Europe/London day boundary; not a per-firm rules engine.

      Edgewonk

      No

      Not built for prop-firm daily-loss rule tracking.

    • Data export

      Gold Hunts

      Yes

      CSV and JSON export of your own gold history, plus public JSON endpoints at /gold-data.

      Edgewonk

      Yes

      Journal data is yours and exportable; the product is a licensed desktop-style journal.

    • Mobile

      Gold Hunts

      Yes

      Installable PWA — works from the browser on iOS and Android, no app store.

      Edgewonk

      Partial

      Not positioned as a mobile-first journal.

    • Free tier

      Gold Hunts

      Yes

      Free with no trade cap and no card required.

      Edgewonk

      No

      No free tier; a 14-day money-back guarantee is advertised instead.

    • Price

      Gold Hunts

      Yes

      £0.

      Edgewonk

      Yes

      US$169 for a one-year plan, or US$197 for 16 months, excluding EU/UK VAT; price advertised as locked for life.

    Edgewonk pricing above is taken from the public pricing page at edgewonk.com/pricing, checked 23 August 2026. VAT applies in the EU and UK. Their page is authoritative.

    BEST FOR

    Choose on the failure you are trying to fix, not on the feature list.

    • You keep breaking your own rules and need to confront it in writing: Edgewonk.
    • You want the gold record built for you and reviewed weekly: Gold Hunts.
    • You trade several instruments and want one psychology framework across all of them: Edgewonk.
    • You want XAUUSD session, sweep and spread-cost reporting with no setup: Gold Hunts.
    • You want to spend nothing while you are still proving an edge: Gold Hunts.

    DOES IT UNDERSTAND GOLD?

    Edgewonk is instrument-agnostic. It will track XAUUSD as competently as it tracks EURUSD, which is to say it stores what you tell it and analyses your custom criteria against your results. There is no built-in notion that a gold lot is 100 ounces or that the 12:00–16:00 UTC overlap behaves differently from 03:00 UTC.

    You can construct a gold view — a custom criterion for session, another for sweep-versus-continuation, another for whether a US data release was inside the holding period. It works, and traders do it. The cost is that every trade needs that metadata typed in correctly and consistently, forever, and the analysis is only as honest as the moment you were in when you filled the form.

    Gold Hunts derives all three automatically from the execution timestamp and the price path, which removes both the labour and the hindsight bias, but gives you nothing about how you felt.

    WHERE EDGEWONK IS GENUINELY STRONGER

    Psychology. The Tiltmeter, emotional tagging and the enforced habit of writing the trade up are the point of the product, and no automated importer replaces them. Traders whose losses come from revenge sizing after a stopped gold scalp are describing an Edgewonk problem, not a data problem.

    One-off cost structure. A one-year plan at US$169 with the price locked for life, rather than an open-ended monthly subscription, is genuinely cheaper over several years than most SaaS journals.

    Maturity and independence. It is a long-established product that does not depend on broker integrations continuing to work.

    MIGRATION NOTES

    These two are complements more often than substitutes, which is the honest recommendation: let Gold Hunts hold the objective gold record and keep Edgewonk for the written reflection if that is what fixes your behaviour.

    If you are replacing Edgewonk outright, export your journal first — the reflections are the valuable part and they are not reconstructible from broker data. Gold Hunts rebuilds the trade record from your MetaTrader 5 history, including gold trades you took before you signed up.

    Do not migrate mid-review-cycle. Finish the month in the tool you started it in, then compare the two reports side by side on the same trades.

    THE GOLD ARITHMETIC A GENERAL TOOL DOES NOT ASSUME

    One XAUUSD lot is 100 ounces. A $1.00 move in the gold price is therefore $100 per 1.00 lot, $10 per 0.10 lot and $1 per 0.01 lot. Everything else — stop distance, spread cost, position size — falls out of that single conversion, and a tool that does not know it cannot tell you what your risk actually was.

    Spread on gold is quoted in cents. A 25-cent spread costs $25 per round turn per 1.00 lot before commission; through a United States inflation release the same symbol can quote $1.50 or wider, which is $150 per round turn per lot for the same trade you took an hour earlier. Read across a month of scalps, that difference decides whether the strategy is viable.

    Session windows matter as much as levels. London runs 07:00–16:00 UTC and New York 12:00–21:00 UTC, with the overlap from 12:00 to 16:00 UTC carrying most of gold's daily range expansion. A journal that reports "morning" and "afternoon" in your local time hides the only boundaries gold respects.

    • Contract: 1.00 lot XAUUSD = 100 ounces
    • $1.00 gold move = $100 per 1.00 lot
    • 25-cent spread = $25 per round turn per 1.00 lot
    • London 07:00–16:00 UTC, New York 12:00–21:00 UTC, overlap 12:00–16:00 UTC

    WHAT THIS PAGE DOES NOT CLAIM

    No ratings, scores, testimonials or user counts appear on this page, because none could be verified. What is compared is feature presence, published price and whether the tool models gold correctly.

    Gold Hunts publishes no profit or return figures for any product, including its own. Performance is reported only as a win rate on a disclosed trade count with losing calls left visible on the public ledger.

    RISK NOTE

    Leveraged gold carries a high risk of rapid loss. Everything on this page is education, not financial advice or a projection of returns.

    GOLD TRADING FAQ

    How much does Edgewonk cost?
    Edgewonk's pricing page advertises US$169 for a one-year plan or US$197 for sixteen months, excluding EU and UK VAT, with a 14-day money-back guarantee and the price locked in for life (checked 23 August 2026).
    Is Edgewonk better than a free journal?
    For behavioural work, often yes — the manual write-up and Tiltmeter are the product. For an objective gold record, a free automated journal that syncs MT5 gives you cleaner data with no entry bias.
    Does Edgewonk have gold session analysis?
    Not preset. You can build time-of-day segmentation with custom criteria, but London and New York gold windows are not defined for you the way they are in a gold-only journal.
    Can I use both Edgewonk and Gold Hunts?
    Yes, and for many gold traders that is the right answer: automated objective statistics on one side, written psychological review on the other.
    Does Gold Hunts have anything like the Tiltmeter?
    No. Gold Hunts measures execution against plan — stop moved, target cut early, entry versus intended level — but it does not score emotional state. If that is your core problem, Edgewonk addresses it directly.

    RELATED READING

    COMPARE IT ON YOUR OWN DATA

    Live XAUUSD signals on a public ledger, a free gold trade journal that syncs with MetaTrader 5, and the macro pulse before the London open.

    MORE IN THIS COMPARISON